Overview
In March 2005, The NYPL launched the Digital Gallery, providing free access to over 275,000 images, effectively acting as a digital gateway to world-renowned cultural and historical documents. Nearly three years later and another quarter million images, the Digital Gallery has taken a look inward as well as forward in preparing for the next big stage in its evolution.
During July 2007, I joined the Digital Library Program to co-conduct an evaluation of the website to identify its strengths, weaknesses, and future goals.
Project Goals
- Evaluate the website taxonomy and organization for strengths and weaknesses.
- Conduct a comparative evaluation to identify conventions and standards within online digital collections.
- Review current Web 2.0 trends and new technologies for potential inclusion in the website redesign.
- Design and implement a series of on-site usability tests to identify key strengths and weaknesses.
- Develop personas based on archetypal users for use in future design iterations.
Outcomes
The full report can be accessed on the NYPL Labs website.
What’s Going Well
- Usability testing revealed users find the website to be a good resource for visual documents.
- The comparative evaluation of similar online resources showed the Digital Gallery excels in content, presentation, and functionality.
- The comparative evaluation also showed the Digital Gallery as having a faster and more searchable database.
What Needs Improving
- Users feel the website is complex and somewhat difficult to use for directed searches.
- The Search tool does not support current conventions for handling pluralization, misspellings, and natural language queries; this conflicts with the expectations of users who are accustomed to using Google, Yahoo!, and AskJeeves search engines.
- The layout and design has caused some unintended scoping issues for global vs. section-level navigation.
Looking Forward
- The website should begin to feature more contextual tools such as the Collection Guides. Lesson guides for teachers is an effective way to conduct community outreach and build a user base.
- Being an early adopter of web trends that are likely to become conventions will keep the Digital Gallery at the forefront. This includes folksonomy (tagging) and social and collaborative networking.
- Supporting user behavior to reuse the website’s content on their own websites, in the classroom, or for various arts and crafts projects will foster community involvement and interaction. Making the collections portable via RSS is one potential solution for enabling this user behavior.
Tools and Methods
- One-on-One Usability Tests
- Comparative Evaluation
- Functionality Matrix
- Persona and Scenario Development